Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Blown resistor in automotive latching relay

A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
Hi all. This is my first post to this NG forum, so please be kind.

I am trying to repair a 12v latching relay for my Volkswagen Beetle
(~1975). It controls the dimming of the headlights (hi/lo).

The trigger is a momentary ground signal (S) which actuates the coil.
The arm that the coil pulls on has a plunger which toggles a rather
complicated see-saw arm which moves a contact between posts 56a &
56b. Also attached to the arm is a contact which connects to both
outputs (56a & 56b) while the arm is being pulled (I can actually only
see where it connects to terminal 56b on the actual relay). The
diagram may be a bit off since only one of the outputs is "hot" during
actual operation.

The below diagram came from the relay casing. Here is a pic w/ the
circuit diagram screened on the outside of the casing:
http://www2.cip1.com/PhotoGallery.asp?ProductCode=VWC-111-941-583
I've added all the terminal labels in parentheis.
The BAT terminal has constant 12v(+). The IGN terminal has 12v(+)
when both the ignition and the headlight switch are ON. The GRD is
connected to the momentary switch on the turn signal (I've confirmed
it grounds when pressed). The 56a & 56b circuits power the HI/LO beam
circuits, respectively. These are fused after this relay which means
this relay must flow all the current for the headlights.
I believe the mark on the contact that swings between the two outputs
indicates it is a latching contact which stays closed to one of the
outputs until the next activation of the coil.
The extra "swinging" contact to the very right of the diagram would
seem to apply power to both outputs for the brief time that the coil
is energized. The result is that you can dim the headlights w/o the
IGN being on and the headlights will momentarily light up.

The HI circuit is fused w/ two 16A fuses in parallel (total 32A), one
for each headlight. The LO is fused w/ two 8A fuses in parallel
(total 16A).

+-----------------------+
IGN | |
+(56)------|-------------+ |
| | |
BAT | | |
+(30)>-----+-------+ | |
| | + +
| | \ \
R? COIL=====\====<====\
| | \ \
MOM | | / \
GND(S)>----+-------+ + \+ + \
| | |
+-----+---+
| |
(56a) (56b)
HI LO


My problem appears to be the resistor located in parallel w/ the
coil. It is obviously burnt out on my relay. It looks like it
"popped". It is mostly black and I cannot make out the colored
stripes to determine the rating.
I'm assuming the resistor was protecting the coil. If it were to burn
out, wouldn't the coil then take the full current/voltage? I haven't
taken the relay apart enough to test the coil separately, but wired
normally it wasn't activating (which is why I opened up the relay).

While I could buy a new relay for around $20USD this one was brand new
and lasted only a day (it replaced an old one that had lasted 30-
yrs!) I'm not sure if that says the quality is bad, or my car's
headlight circuit is at fault. The HI circuit was upped to 16A fuses
by the previous owner to accomodate Halogen lights. I know the wiring
can handle the current, but maybe the components can't?

Any suggestions for replacing the resistor? The original was very
small - about 5mm long and 2mm in dia. What should the rating be?
Would it help if I clipped the resistor and measured the current
through the coil? Could I replace it w/ a diode (1A, 50v)?



AshMan40
 
T

Tom Biasi

Jan 1, 1970
0
AshMan40 said:
Hi all. This is my first post to this NG forum, so please be kind.

I am trying to repair a 12v latching relay for my Volkswagen Beetle
(~1975). It controls the dimming of the headlights (hi/lo).

The trigger is a momentary ground signal (S) which actuates the coil.
The arm that the coil pulls on has a plunger which toggles a rather
complicated see-saw arm which moves a contact between posts 56a &
56b. Also attached to the arm is a contact which connects to both
outputs (56a & 56b) while the arm is being pulled (I can actually only
see where it connects to terminal 56b on the actual relay). The
diagram may be a bit off since only one of the outputs is "hot" during
actual operation.

The below diagram came from the relay casing. Here is a pic w/ the
circuit diagram screened on the outside of the casing:
http://www2.cip1.com/PhotoGallery.asp?ProductCode=VWC-111-941-583
I've added all the terminal labels in parentheis.
The BAT terminal has constant 12v(+). The IGN terminal has 12v(+)
when both the ignition and the headlight switch are ON. The GRD is
connected to the momentary switch on the turn signal (I've confirmed
it grounds when pressed). The 56a & 56b circuits power the HI/LO beam
circuits, respectively. These are fused after this relay which means
this relay must flow all the current for the headlights.
I believe the mark on the contact that swings between the two outputs
indicates it is a latching contact which stays closed to one of the
outputs until the next activation of the coil.
The extra "swinging" contact to the very right of the diagram would
seem to apply power to both outputs for the brief time that the coil
is energized. The result is that you can dim the headlights w/o the
IGN being on and the headlights will momentarily light up.

The HI circuit is fused w/ two 16A fuses in parallel (total 32A), one
for each headlight. The LO is fused w/ two 8A fuses in parallel
(total 16A).

+-----------------------+
IGN | |
+(56)------|-------------+ |
| | |
BAT | | |
+(30)>-----+-------+ | |
| | + +
| | \ \
R? COIL=====\====<====\
| | \ \
MOM | | / \
GND(S)>----+-------+ + \+ + \
| | |
+-----+---+
| |
(56a) (56b)
HI LO


My problem appears to be the resistor located in parallel w/ the
coil. It is obviously burnt out on my relay. It looks like it
"popped". It is mostly black and I cannot make out the colored
stripes to determine the rating.
I'm assuming the resistor was protecting the coil. If it were to burn
out, wouldn't the coil then take the full current/voltage? I haven't
taken the relay apart enough to test the coil separately, but wired
normally it wasn't activating (which is why I opened up the relay).

While I could buy a new relay for around $20USD this one was brand new
and lasted only a day (it replaced an old one that had lasted 30-
yrs!) I'm not sure if that says the quality is bad, or my car's
headlight circuit is at fault. The HI circuit was upped to 16A fuses
by the previous owner to accomodate Halogen lights. I know the wiring
can handle the current, but maybe the components can't?

Any suggestions for replacing the resistor? The original was very
small - about 5mm long and 2mm in dia. What should the rating be?
Would it help if I clipped the resistor and measured the current
through the coil? Could I replace it w/ a diode (1A, 50v)?



AshMan40



Sounds like you have a bi-stable relay. One click one way another click the
other way. Mechanical failure is common in those.
Are you sure the device across the coil is a resistor? Some had a diode in
reverse.

If you added Halogen lights to a car that did not have them and kept the
stock relay you are asking for trouble.

Tom
 
R

Rich Grise

Jan 1, 1970
0
While I could buy a new relay for around $20USD this one was brand new
and lasted only a day (it replaced an old one that had lasted 30-
yrs!) I'm not sure if that says the quality is bad, or my car's
headlight circuit is at fault.

If the one blew out after 30 years, and then a new one blew out in a day,
either the new unit was defective, or there's another problem in the
electrical system you'll have to diagnose, or have someone fix it for you.

Good Luck!
Rich
 
A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
Sounds like you have a bi-stable relay. One click one way another click the
other way. Mechanical failure is common in those.
Are you sure the device across the coil is a resistor? Some had a diode in
reverse.

I thought it might be a diode since I have seen diodes wired in
parallel across other relay coils. I'm not sure. It is shaped like a
resistor, but is burnt/chared so badly I can't tell. It has a few
stripes around the body that are charred black, but I guess there are
diodes that look like this too.

The reason I said resistor was based on the below article I found
while looking for a solution to my problem. It talks about using
resistors, diodes and other things to prevent relay contacts from
welding themselves together.
http://relays.tycoelectronics.com/appnotes/app_pdfs/13c3311.pdf

The "cheapest" solution appears to be a resistor. And since this
relay died in a day, I'd say it was REALLY cheap! :)

I'm going to dig up my MM and test the continuity thur the coil. If
it's open (fried) then there's no hope in fixing this.

Does anyone have any suggestions for building a solid state
replacement for this type of relay? I was thinking I could use a
cheap 40A SPDT relay to switch between the 56a & 56b terminals (that
way it can handle the current flow of the Halogens), but have a simple
solid state circuit handle the "bi-stable" portion of the circuit.

Or better yet, a completely solid state circuit w/ no moving parts! I
could always add relays at each headlight circuit to reduce the
current flow thru this circuit.



AshMan40
 
U

Unkown

Jan 1, 1970
0
Normally what you think is a resistor should be a 24V 1/2 watt zener diode,
which is used to absorb the transient voltages when the relay coil is
energized and de-energized. It is connected with the cathode(the bar)
towards the +ve supply voltage. Sometimes an inverse 1N4004 is used instead
of a zener diode, but a zener diode is better. The zener can absorb both the
positive and negative transients.
In recent years, a resistor is used instead of a zener diode in order to
save money. They all serve the same purpose.
 
A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
Normally what you think is a resistor should be a 24V 1/2 watt zener diode,
which is used to absorb the transient voltages when the relay coil is
energized and de-energized. It is connected with the cathode(the bar)
towards the +ve supply voltage. Sometimes an inverse 1N4004 is used instead
of a zener diode, but a zener diode is better. The zener can absorb both the
positive and negative transients.
In recent years, a resistor is used instead of a zener diode in order to
save money. They all serve the same purpose.

Tore my relay apart today. De-soldered the thing I thought to be a
resistor and it was. It measures 98ohms on my MM, in both
directions. Does that mean it is a resistor, or would a zener diode
show resistance? If it is a resistor, since it is much smaller than
my 100ohm/1W resistor I'm guessing the power rating is much lower (I
still can't make out the colored stripes). Check out the pics below
and maybe you can decide if it is a resistor or a diode.

With the resistor off I could measure the resistance thru the coil....
infinite. :-( My coil is shot. Time to dump the relay and go to
Plan B. I've ordered a German-made dimmer relay which I hope to be
more reliable.

In case anyone is interested, here are some pics of the inner workings
of the relay. Quite interesting for a "bi-stable" latching relay.
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347211.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347212.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347215.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347217.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347218.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347219.jpg


AshMan40
 
J

John Popelish

Jan 1, 1970
0
AshMan40 said:
Tore my relay apart today. De-soldered the thing I thought to be a
resistor and it was. It measures 98ohms on my MM, in both
directions. Does that mean it is a resistor, or would a zener diode
show resistance? If it is a resistor, since it is much smaller than
my 100ohm/1W resistor I'm guessing the power rating is much lower (I
still can't make out the colored stripes). Check out the pics below
and maybe you can decide if it is a resistor or a diode.

With the resistor off I could measure the resistance thru the coil....
infinite. :-( My coil is shot. Time to dump the relay and go to
Plan B. I've ordered a German-made dimmer relay which I hope to be
more reliable.

In case anyone is interested, here are some pics of the inner workings
of the relay. Quite interesting for a "bi-stable" latching relay.
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347211.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347212.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347215.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347217.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347218.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347219.jpg

You are having way too much fun with this problem. ;-)
 
E

ehsjr

Jan 1, 1970
0
AshMan40 said:
Tore my relay apart today. De-soldered the thing I thought to be a
resistor and it was. It measures 98ohms on my MM, in both
directions. Does that mean it is a resistor, or would a zener diode
show resistance? If it is a resistor, since it is much smaller than
my 100ohm/1W resistor I'm guessing the power rating is much lower (I
still can't make out the colored stripes). Check out the pics below
and maybe you can decide if it is a resistor or a diode.

With the resistor off I could measure the resistance thru the coil....
infinite. :-( My coil is shot. Time to dump the relay and go to
Plan B. I've ordered a German-made dimmer relay which I hope to be
more reliable.

In case anyone is interested, here are some pics of the inner workings
of the relay. Quite interesting for a "bi-stable" latching relay.
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347211.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347212.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347215.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347217.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347218.jpg
http://images.thesamba.com/vw/gallery/pix/347219.jpg


AshMan40

Nice pictures! It is definitely a resistor.

Ed
 
G

GPG

Jan 1, 1970
0
Nice pictures! It is definitely a resistor.

Ed- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Possibly some fault is holding the relay on for extended periods,
burning the coil and the resistor out.
 
A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
I've tried replacing my dimmer relay w/ three cheaper 30A (Bosch-
style) relays. The first relay below on the left is the relay for the
headlight switch. The relay to the bottom right is for the "dimmer"
which switches between hi/low beams. The third relay at the top right
allows the dimmer switch to act as a "daylight flash" when used while
the headlight switch is off. The single switch to the very right
controls both right-hand relays via their coil ground.

BAT
+(30)>--------+ +--(30)>--------+
| | |
(85)>--+ | +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | +
GND | \ | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+
| | | | | | |
| | | | | (87) (87a)
HL SW (87) (87a) | +-|<----+ |
| | | 1Ax2 | | /
| | | +-|<----+ | /
| +---+ | +---|-----+ +--GND
| | | | HI LIGHT
+---------+---|----(30)>--+ | SW
| | | |
| (85)>--+ | |
| | + |
| | \ |
| COIL==<==\= |
| | \ |
| | \ |
+--(86)>--+ + \+
| |
| |
(87) (87a)


Problem, when wired as above the circuit works, but there is a loud
buzzing from one of the right two relays. Above you can see I've
added diodes between the two terminals (#85, #86) that are grounded by
the HI LIGHT switch (one each) to limit this part of the circuit to
negative flow only (cathodes towards terminals). This helped to
prevent the relays from buzzing all the time. Still, the relays
"buzz" when the HI LIGHT switch is turned on.
If I remove one of the right two relays the remaining circuit works
fine. I believe it has something to do w/ using a common ground
switch between the two right relays.

Any idea how I can get this circuit to work? I was thinking of
switching to a DPST switch at the right.



AshMan40
 
A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
Sorry there is an error in the above diagram. Here is the correct
one.

BAT
+(30)>--------+ +--(30)>--------+
| | |
(85)>--+ | +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | +
GND | \ | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+
| | | | | | |
| | | | | (87) (87a)
HL SW (87) (87a) | +-|<----+ | /
| | | 1Ax2 | | /
| | | +-|<----+---|----------+ +--GND
| +---+ | +-----+ HI LIGHT
| | | SW
+---------+---|----(30)>--+ |
| | | |
| (85)>--+ | |
| | + |
| | \ |
| COIL==<==\= |
| | \ |
| | \ |
+--(86)>--+ + \+
| |
| |
(87) (87a)





AshMan40
 
E

ehsjr

Jan 1, 1970
0
AshMan40 said:
Sorry there is an error in the above diagram. Here is the correct
one.

BAT
+(30)>--------+ +--(30)>--------+
| | |
(85)>--+ | +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | +
GND | \ | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+
| | | | | | |
| | | | | (87) (87a)
HL SW (87) (87a) | +-|<----+ | /
| | | 1Ax2 | | /
| | | +-|<----+---|----------+ +--GND
| +---+ | +-----+ HI LIGHT
| | | SW
+---------+---|----(30)>--+ |
| | | |
| (85)>--+ | |
| | + |
| | \ |
| COIL==<==\= |
| | \ |
| | \ |
+--(86)>--+ + \+
| |
| |
(87) (87a)





AshMan40

Your diodes are drawn backwards, and the connection
from 87 upper right to 87A lower right is wrong. You
need a connection from 87 of the daylight flash relay
(upper right) to 86 of the headlight relay (upper left)
and 4700uF from 85 of the flash relay (upper right) to
gnd. See modified diagram below.

I suspect that is not the end of the story. (For one
thing, I left out transorb protection for the cap)
As you drew it, it appears the HI LIGHT switch is
not a momentary switch. If that's true, I think
you're home free with the addition of a transorb
across the cap and a series resistor. But first,
try the circuit. My bet is that the HI LIGHT switch
is momentary, and a different circuit will be needed
for hi/low to work properly. I think that the high
beam will come on when you activate the switch, and
return to low beam when you release it, regardless
of the daylight flash circuit.

Ed

BAT
+(30)>--------+ +----+--(30)>--------+
| | | |
(85)>--+ | 4700uF +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | | +
GND | \ Gnd | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+
| | | | | | | |
| | | | | | (87) (87a)
HL SW | (87) (87a) | +->|----+ | /
| | | | 1Ax2 | | /
| | | | +->|----+---|----------+ +--GND
| | +---+ | | HI LIGHT
| | | | SW
+---- | ----------- | ----------+
| |
+---------+---|----(30)>--+
| | |
| (85)>--+ |
| | +
| | \
| COIL==<==\=
| | \
| | \
+--(86)>--+ + \+
| |
| |
(87) (87a)
 
A

AshMan40

Jan 1, 1970
0
Your diodes are drawn backwards, and the connection
from 87 upper right to 87A lower right is wrong. You
need a connection from 87 of the daylight flash relay
(upper right) to 86 of the headlight relay (upper left)
and 4700uF from 85 of the flash relay (upper right) to
gnd. See modified diagram below.

I suspect that is not the end of the story. (For one
thing, I left out transorb protection for the cap)
As you drew it, it appears the HI LIGHT switch is
not a momentary switch. If that's true, I think
you're home free with the addition of a transorb
across the cap and a series resistor. But first,
try the circuit. My bet is that the HI LIGHT switch
is momentary, and a different circuit will be needed
for hi/low to work properly. I think that the high
beam will come on when you activate the switch, and
return to low beam when you release it, regardless
of the daylight flash circuit.

Ed

Thanks Ed. Actually the HI LIGHT switch is a SPDT non-momentary
switch.
What is the function of the 4700uF cap? It would appear to store a
charge to keep the flash relay on even after the headlight relay is on
and power is cut to the flash relay.

After posting my last diagram and staring at it for 10-min I realized
that the power going to the lower right relay's 87a connection would
also continue on and power the HI/LO RELAY (lower right). As soon as
teh HI/LO RELAY went on it would cut off it's own power and switch
off. It would then toggle back and forth on/off really quickly. This
is the buzz I was hearing. I've come up with this new design that
disconnects the HI/LO RELAY while the FLASH RELAY is on. I've also
corrected the diodes (thanks Ed).

BAT
+(30)>--------+------------(30)>--------+
| |
(85)>--+ | +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | +
GND | \ | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+---------------+
| | | | | | | |
| | | | | (87) (87a) |
HL SW(+) (87) (87a) | +->|----+ | / |
| | | 1Ax2 | | / |
| +---+ +->|----+---|----------+ +--GND |
| | +-----+ HI LIGHT |
| | | SW |
+-------------|----(30)>--+ | |
| | | |
(85)>--+ | | |
| + | |
| \ | |
COIL==<==\= | |
| \ | |
| \ | |
+--(86)>--+ + \+ |
| | | |
| HI BEAM (87) (87a) LO BEAM |
| |
| |
+-------------------------------------+

It's raining now, so I won't be able to try this until later this
week. Doesn anyone see a problem w/ it?


AshMan40
 
J

jasen

Jan 1, 1970
0
Sorry there is an error in the above diagram. Here is the correct
one.

BAT
+(30)>--------+ +--(30)>--------+
| | |
(85)>--+ | +--(85)>--+ |
| | + | | +
GND | \ | | \
COIL==<==\= | COIL==<==\=
| \ | | \
| \ | | \
(86)>--+ + \+ | (86)>--+ + \+
| | | | | | |
| | | | | (87) (87a)
HL SW (87) (87a) | +-|<----+ | /
| | | 1Ax2 | | /
| | | +-|<----+---|----------+ +--GND
| +---+ | +-----+ HI LIGHT
| | | SW
+---------+---|----(30)>--+ |
| | | |
| (85)>--+ | |
| | + |
| | \ |
| COIL==<==\= |
| | \ |
| | \ |
+--(86)>--+ + \+
| |
| |
(87) (87a)

the buzzing is probably caused buy currents flowing throgh the relay coil
to the headlamp filament which you didn't show.

more info on the intended function and outputs of this cicuit would help.

Bye.
Jasen
 
Top