Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Common Mode Noise Filter Question

Wireaddict

Oct 13, 2017
17
Joined
Oct 13, 2017
Messages
17
One of my hobbies is low frequency radio listening & one of the challenges is the high noise level from atmospheric & man-made interference. To help alleviate the problem I have installed common mode filters at the antenna/ground leads & at the AC line between an isolation transformer & the receiver. I have a question though, which included sketch shows the connect connections? (Hopefully they will show up clearly.) Thanks for the assistance!upload_2018-1-30_0-2-31.png
 

Harald Kapp

Moderator
Moderator
Nov 17, 2011
13,700
Joined
Nov 17, 2011
Messages
13,700
A, A and only A.

The idea of a common mode choke is that the perating current, which is differential current, creates opposing magnetic fileds within the core. These fields cancel one another such that there is (alomos) no impedance to the differential current.
Common mode (noise) currents, however create magnetic fields within each coil that add up to one strong magnetic field within the core, thus creating a high impedance to block common mode noise.

In your circuit B the rolses of common mode and differential mode currents are swapped.
 

Wireaddict

Oct 13, 2017
17
Joined
Oct 13, 2017
Messages
17
A, A and only A.

The idea of a common mode choke is that the perating current, which is differential current, creates opposing magnetic fileds within the core. These fields cancel one another such that there is (alomos) no impedance to the differential current.
Common mode (noise) currents, however create magnetic fields within each coil that add up to one strong magnetic field within the core, thus creating a high impedance to block common mode noise.

In your circuit B the rolses of common mode and differential mode currents are swapped.

Thanks Harald, good explanation; I researched this online but it was never totally clear til now. Regards!
 

tedstruk

Jan 7, 2012
476
Joined
Jan 7, 2012
Messages
476
Its my belief that the signal to noise ratio probably won't change with induced current. But it's probably be best to use individual coils rather than tapped or double coils. I think that one coil induces a frequency and the other probably induces another. wouldn't really matter how they were hooked up. The two are definitely going to feedback and that may be where the noise is coming from. In a guitar, if you tap a single coil it makes a distortion. the type of core is going to matter too, so try to use air cores whenever your in a radio set.
 

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
Its my belief that the signal to noise ratio probably won't change with induced current. But it's probably be best to use individual coils rather than tapped or double coils. I think that one coil induces a frequency and the other probably induces another. wouldn't really matter how they were hooked up. The two are definitely going to feedback and that may be where the noise is coming from.
Your beliefs do not align with fact.

It *never* is best to use individual coils. A high-performance AC powerline common mode filter *requires* that two identical inductors be wound on a single core made of something other than air. And how they are hooked up not only matters, it is critical (see post #2). The coils do not "induce" different frequencies, and the "feedback" you mention is how relatively small core sizes can handle large line currents.

To see how the pro's do it, go through any Corcom, Schurter, or Delta power line filter catalog and study the internal schematics.

ak
 
Top