M
mike
- Jan 1, 1970
- 0
There seems to be some ambiguity in terms, so, for the purpose
of this discussion...
An ELECTRONIC air filter uses kilovolts to create an electric
field that charges particles so they get attracted to a surface.
An ELECTROSTATIC air filter is a passive device that generates
the electric field by passing air across some dielectric medium.
The advertising is full of vague marketing speak with dimensionless
graphs and no real statements as to how they work for pollen particles.
Most pleated furnace filters have some electrostatic features.
For some vendors, it's their primary focus. The Filtrete line
mentions almost as a footnote.
I can't imagine much voltage being generated, so I set about to
measure it. I inserted electrodes under the outer polyethylene
(I think it's poly) mesh on either side and blasted air thru it.
I measured zero volts.
Ok, maybe not much current.
I put a .1uF high voltage cap across the electrodes and let it charge
for a while. I touched a scope probe to the cap with a trigger
level of 1V. I expected to see the peak voltage and the decay
of the .1uF and the 10M scope input.
I saw zero.
Is my measurement technique faulty?
Am I measuring the wrong thing?
Or are electrostatic filters made of snake oil?
Thanks, mike
of this discussion...
An ELECTRONIC air filter uses kilovolts to create an electric
field that charges particles so they get attracted to a surface.
An ELECTROSTATIC air filter is a passive device that generates
the electric field by passing air across some dielectric medium.
The advertising is full of vague marketing speak with dimensionless
graphs and no real statements as to how they work for pollen particles.
Most pleated furnace filters have some electrostatic features.
For some vendors, it's their primary focus. The Filtrete line
mentions almost as a footnote.
I can't imagine much voltage being generated, so I set about to
measure it. I inserted electrodes under the outer polyethylene
(I think it's poly) mesh on either side and blasted air thru it.
I measured zero volts.
Ok, maybe not much current.
I put a .1uF high voltage cap across the electrodes and let it charge
for a while. I touched a scope probe to the cap with a trigger
level of 1V. I expected to see the peak voltage and the decay
of the .1uF and the 10M scope input.
I saw zero.
Is my measurement technique faulty?
Am I measuring the wrong thing?
Or are electrostatic filters made of snake oil?
Thanks, mike