Ernst said:
I am looking for a very cheap clock generator (e.g. as an input for a
4020). I don't want to use an oscillator module, since that is too
expensive for my application. Instead I'm thinking of a crystal, a
cap, a transistor and some other simple stuff. Since I only have
experience in digital IC design, I'm seeking for some advice how to
build such a circuit.
Thanks for your help in advance.
Ernst.
Cost shouldn't be a factor if this is a single project. And if
it is a production item, you need to look at circuit board space
of both scenarios, and the cost of all the components.
Keep in mind that if you are building in quantity, price will go
down.
I'm not sure there is a big price difference between an oscillatorin a can
and a crystal at the same frequency. If you choose the wrong frequency,
cost may go up because it will have to be custom made, whether it is
a crystal or complete oscillator. If you are't on a frequency where you
can get cheap oscillators in cans, then you might want to look at the
overall design and see if something can be changed to accomodate a common
and cheap frequency.
It might be cheaper, depending on the frequency, to go to a non-crystal
oscillator. But you have to make sure that your design does not
need the stability or even accuracy of a crystal. In production,
if you have to adjust something to an exact frequency it may be more
costly overall than a crystal (or crystal oscillator). But if you can
get away with an RC oscillator, then you may find you don't need the
divider, since it's easier (and often better) for an RC oscillator at
a lower frequency. Note that many designs may use a crystal (discrete
or in a prefabricated oscillator) because its cost even with a
divider to get it down to the needed frequency is less than the cost
and trouble of an RC oscillator (especially in a production setting),
even if stability is not an issue.
Michael