Maker Pro
Maker Pro

STOP 2nd phone line from ringing

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
I wonder if anyone has an idea how to prevent a phone from sensing the ring signal.
Here is the reason.
My voip provider (phonepower) has a box that line one and line two plug into. Phonepower provides a cloned 2nd line for free so if someone is on line 1, you can click over to line 2 and make a call. The big problem is when phonepower rings my phone, both lines ring, first one, then the next. Very annoying and phonepower has no provision to stop line 2 from ringing.
My thoughts are to build a circuit on line 2 after it exits the phonebox to silence the ring signal, but still allow me to get a dial tone when needed.
I find many circuits to make a phone ring, but none to stop it.

Is it as simple as rectifying the ac voltage? Or will this cause other problems with all the connected phones?
Any ideas?
 
Last edited:

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
If the phone has a ringer that is separate from the receiver (speaker), then disconnecting the ring device will stop all ringing without affecting any other functions in that or other phones.

ak
 

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
If the phone has a ringer that is separate from the receiver (speaker), then disconnecting the ring device will stop all ringing without affecting any other functions in that or other phones.

ak
Thanks for the reply, but it is not that simple. Line 2 comes out of the voip phonebox which connects to my punchdown phone block where 8 phones are connected. In other words, what comes out of this box feeds all the phones in the house.

My thought is if I can put a circuit in series with the line 2 only pair that comes out of this phonepower box it will supress all the line 2 ringers on the phones downline, but leave line one ringers alone. (Line 1 and 2 are on different pairs)
 

Bluejets

Oct 5, 2014
6,901
Joined
Oct 5, 2014
Messages
6,901
Draw a circuit of what you have. Normally ring voltage is much higher than line. Also depends on what country you are in as to origin of tone.e.g. here in Aus everything comes from within the modem (NBN).
 

davenn

Moderator
Sep 5, 2009
14,254
Joined
Sep 5, 2009
Messages
14,254
Draw a circuit of what you have. Normally ring voltage is much higher than line. Also depends on what country you are in as to origin of tone.

again ... this is a VoIP system

there is no separate ringing /line voltage
it's ALL digital signalling and voice

the phones have their own IP address and are basically connected directly to the internet
 

JWHassler

Dec 22, 2014
86
Joined
Dec 22, 2014
Messages
86
When VOIP phones went in here (California), the modem had an output ffor POT units that preserves the use of existing phones.
 

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
If there is no ring signal, but only a ring code (a pretty important detail to leave out), then the only way to stop ringing is to examine the code as it goes by, looking for the ring code, and setting the ring code to non-ring before passing it on to the phones.

ak
 

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
When VOIP phones went in here (California), the modem had an output ffor POT units that preserves the use of existing phones.
You are correct. Each phone is NOT connected to the internet. The modem does have a POT output which all the existing old style telephones connect to. As I said, on the back of the modem phone box there is 2 POT jacks (line one and line 2)
This is USA phone system, so if there was a way to prevent an old style phone from ringing, I am pretty sure it would apply here. Just forget I mentioned VOIP, as I am pretty sure that after it comes out of the modem phonebox, it is just POTS
 

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
Completely eliminating the ring signal would be difficult. What you can do is detect a certain voltage level that reliably reflects the start of ringing, and use that detection to disconnect the downstream phones for 1-2 seconds. If you answer the phone in the middle of a ring, you would not be connected until the 1-2 seconds timed out. Depending on the ring pattern, the timer could be tweaked pretty close to the actual ring burst time.

A potential problem is that the off-hook voltage is significantly lower than the on-hook. This means the ring detector can't look in that direction, or it will disconnect a phone as soon as it is picked up. If the ring voltage starts with a negative half cycle, that will be missed by the detector. Depending on the type and sensitivity in the phones there might be a chirp, but not a full ring.

Note - discussing phone line voltage polarities gets messy because the original system runs on -48 V wrt earth ground, but some new systems that are isolated from the phone system, such as voip phones, use +48 V.

ak
 

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
Completely eliminating the ring signal would be difficult. What you can do is detect a certain voltage level that reliably reflects the start of ringing, and use that detection to disconnect the downstream phones for 1-2 seconds. If you answer the phone in the middle of a ring, you would not be connected until the 1-2 seconds timed out. Depending on the ring pattern, the timer could be tweaked pretty close to the actual ring burst time.

A potential problem is that the off-hook voltage is significantly lower than the on-hook. This means the ring detector can't look in that direction, or it will disconnect a phone as soon as it is picked up. If the ring voltage starts with a negative half cycle, that will be missed by the detector. Depending on the type and sensitivity in the phones there might be a chirp, but not a full ring.

Note - discussing phone line voltage polarities gets messy because the original system runs on -48 V wrt earth ground, but some new systems that are isolated from the phone system, such as voip phones, use +48 V.

ak
Doesnt the voltage chance from dc to ac to initiate the ring and it is the ac that the phones detect that starts the ring? Since I never want line 2 to ring ( can only make outgoing calls on a cloned line), can I not supress the ac so the phones on line 2 will only see a voltage rise and not ac?
Not sure if that would be a direction to look.
 

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
When a phone is on hook voltage is 48 V, continuously. The 90 Vrms ring tone is superimposed on this. The 48 V is not a hard-regulated power supply output, but a 48 V source through an impedance such as 900 ohms. When a phone goes off hook, it loads this soft voltage source and pulls the line voltage down to around 8 Vdc, with about 1/2 volt of bidirectional audio riding on it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ringing_(telephony)

The audio on a phone line also is AC, and is bidirectional, so suppressing (a lot) one frequency in one direction while leaving the bidirectional other frequencies alone would be difficult.

Pretty good overview: http://www.epanorama.net/circuits/teleinterface.html

ak
 

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
When a phone is on hook voltage is 48 V, continuously. The 90 Vrms ring tone is superimposed on this. The 48 V is not a hard-regulated power supply output, but a 48 V source through an impedance such as 900 ohms. When a phone goes off hook, it loads this soft voltage source and pulls the line voltage down to around 8 Vdc, with about 1/2 volt of bidirectional audio riding on it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ringing_(telephony)

The audio on a phone line also is AC, and is bidirectional, so suppressing (a lot) one frequency in one direction while leaving the bidirectional other frequencies alone would be difficult.

Pretty good overview: http://www.epanorama.net/circuits/teleinterface.html

ak
Thanks, after reading all that, I can see how it would be impractical and difficult. Since it is only the time line one is ringing that I need to supress line 2 ringer, I will probably make something that disconnects all the phones on line two while line one rings, then simply reconnect them after line one stops ringing. Or someone picks up.
 

AnalogKid

Jun 10, 2015
2,884
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
2,884
Do you know what the ring voltage frequency is? With the right relay, this can be done with zero active components:
Capacitor
Diode bridge
Filter capacitor
Relay coil

ak
 

Honeymonkey

Jan 15, 2018
6
Joined
Jan 15, 2018
Messages
6
Do you know what the ring voltage frequency is? With the right relay, this can be done with zero active components:
Capacitor
Diode bridge
Filter capacitor
Relay coil

ak
Not off hand. I will have to do a bit more reading on united states pot service when I get a chance. I have a bit of a raid problem to deal with at the moment.
 
Top